Posts Tagged ‘EDMC’

EDMC Whistleblower Case Moves Forward

The whistleblower case filed against Education Management Corporation by James Hoyer Law Firm client Jason Sobek has cleared a major hurdle. U.S. District Court Judge Terrence McVerry in Pittsburgh ruled to deny EDMC’s Motion to Dismiss Sobek’s suit.  The case will proceed on three major counts involving misrepresentations of job placement statistics and accreditation and allegations that EDMC failed to adequately record the Satisfactory Academic Progress of students, whereby allowing its schools to collect federal financial aid to which they were not entitled.

Sobek filed the suit in 2010 against EDMC, the country’s second largest for-profit college provider, after witnessing questionable practices while working as an Admissions Representative at the company.

Oral arguments were presented before Judge McVerry in Pittsburgh on May 13, 2013 by James Hoyer Senior Partner Christopher Casper. In response to today’s ruling, Casper said, “We are encouraged by the Court’s ruling.  It sends a message that companies cannot rake in hundreds of millions of dollars in taxpayer money while blatantly violating federal law.”

In his ruling denying EDMC’s Motion to Dismiss,  the judge wrote “EDMC presents several overarching lines of reasoning in support of dismissal.”  One of EDMC’s arguments claimed that even if the company committed the alleged violations, it would not be grounds for the government to refuse paying its schools federal financial aid.  The judge indicated “such a defense is fact-intensive and would not justify dismissal at the pleading stage.”  As a result, Judge McVerry determined “a final determination is premature at this time” and the case should proceed.

The case will now move on to the discovery phase.  “We look forward to taking depositions and the opportunity to put EDMC under oath,”said Casper.

Three additional counts in the suit were voluntarily dismissed.  One of those regarding “incentive compensation” continues on in a separate whistleblower case filed against EDMC.

 

 

 

 

James Hoyer Client Interviewed in Investigative Report on For-profit Colleges

Jason-Sobek-WFTS

A hard hitting story on WFTS TV, the ABC station in Tampa, exposed questionable practices in recruiting and job placement at the 2nd largest for-profit college company in the nation, Education Management Corporation, known as EDMC.

The company is at the center of a whistleblower lawsuit filed by former EDMC Admissions Representative Jason Sobek, who is represented by the James Hoyer Law Firm.  EDMC operates several for-profit colleges, including The Art Institutes, South University, Argosy University and Brown Mackie College.

In the report, Sobek was interviewed and explained that recruiters at the schools were encouraged to say whatever it takes to sign students up:

“We were trained to target low-income students, single mothers, women staying at women’s shelters,” Sobek said.

 I-Team investigator Michael George asked Sobek why those groups were targeted.

 “They were easy victims,” Sobek said.

 But there was more to it than that. Sobek says low-income students were desired because they qualify for the most federal aid. EDMC’s schools received $1.8 billion dollars in federal grants and loans in 2010 alone, according a report on for-profit schools by the U.S. Senate. That’s taxpayer money.

Click here to read the full report on the WFTS TV website or watch the video below.

 

Powerful Senator Calls for Audit of Job Placement Numbers at For-Profit College EDMC

Senator Dick Durbin

Senator Dick Durbin

U.S. Senator Dick Durbin (D-IL), the Assistant Majority Leader of the Senate, is calling for an audit of what he termed “baseless” job placement numbers reported by Education Management Corporation (EDMC).  Senator Durbin made that request and issued a press release, after reviewing data exposed by whistleblower Jason Sobek, a James Hoyer Law Firm client.

EDMC is the second largest for-profit college provider in the United States.  The company owns The Art Institutes, South University, Argosy University and Brown Mackie College and has more than 150,000 students.  Senator Durbin called for the audit in a letter sent to EDMC’s accrediting agency, the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools (SACS).

Sobek was interviewed by ABC News in a report which investigated questionable job placement statistics reported by the for-profit college company.  Durbin, who was also interviewed in the report, was so concerned he decided to take action by sending the letter, which said, in part:

The lawsuit highlighted in a recent ABC news report against the Education Management Corporation (EDMC) by a former EDMC employee raises serious concerns about the validity of EDMC’s reported job placement rates. I urge you to carefully audit all job placement rates reported by EDMC.

Among the many questionable job placements counted in the data as students successfully working in their field, were an Accounting graduate working as a McDonald’s cashier, a Business Administration graduate working as a Walmart Customer Service Rep, and a Fashion Marketing graduate working as a shoe salesman.

Durbin reviewed the job placement database material and came to this conclusion in the ABC News story:

“It’s just plain fraud and your whistle-blower has brought it to light,” Durbin told ABC News. “These students get sucked in by these ads, sign up for debt, sign up for courses that lead to nowhere,” Durbin says.

In his letter to the SACS, Durbin says he is “deeply concerned” and urges the accrediting body to take action.

Students and families rely on accreditors for the seal of approval you provide. Given the baseless job placement numbers provided by one of EDMC’s schools with SACS accreditation, the Council should re-evaluate current methodology, documentation and reporting requirements for job placement. I urge SACS to audit other schools owned by EDMC to ensure that all of EDMC’s students are working with accurate information about their post-secondary education.

A Federal Magistrate Judge in Pennsylvania recently recommended that Sobek’s case against EDMC move forward. The suit alleges the for-profit college company misrepresented, not only job placement statistics, but also accreditation, and failed to adequately track student academic progress.

The case is a concern for students and taxpayers, because nearly 90-percent of the tuition paid to the company comes from federal loans and grants. Click here to read Senator Durbin’s entire press release.

 

 

For-profit College Whistleblower Interviewed on ABC World News

JasonSobekMS-EDMC-3

Whistleblower Jason Sobek

The whistleblower case against for-profit college giant Education Management Corporation (EDMC) was profiled in an investigative report on ABC World News.  James Hoyer Client Jason Sobek was interviewed and explained why he came forward to expose practices he believes are hurting, not only students, but also taxpayers.

Reporter Mark Greenblatt shared internal documents that show EDMC falsely inflated job placement statistics.

“They manipulated the job placement rates by counting students working in a job that they did not need the degree for,” Sobek told ABC News. “In my opinion, it’s a wretched fraud.”

EDMC is the 2nd largest for-profit college operator in the country.  It owns The Art Institutes, Brown Mackie, South University and Argosy University.  Sobek is a former Assistant Director of Admissions who recruited students to sign up for South University Online.

The story also profiles Brown Mackie student Sarah Fisher who graduated with an Associate’s Degree in Business Management.  Fisher works as a Customer Service Representative at Walmart, a job she found on her own while still attending school.  Since graduating, she’s been unable to find a job in her field of study, but internal EDMC documents show the school counted her as a successful job placement.

In addition, the documents Sobek shared show a Fashion Marketing graduate who works as a shoe salesman and an Accounting graduate who works as a McDonald’s cashier were also counted as successful job placements. Sobek believes counting these graduates as successful job placements is misleading.  He says the company uses them to inflate job placement statistics presented to potential students to get them to sign up and get their financial aid dollars.

ABC News asked U.S. Senator Dick Durbin, the Assistant Majority Leader of the Senate, to review the internal EDMC job placement records.  After his review, Senator Durbin issued a powerful rebuke.

“It’s just plain fraud and your whistle-blower has brought it to light,” Durbin told ABC News. “These students get sucked in by these ads, sign up for debt, sign up for courses that lead to nowhere,” Durbin says.

Click here to watch the ABC World News story and to read the online report.  You can also post a comment on the ABC News website.

 

Magistrate Judge Recommends Case Against EDMC Move Forward

Positive news for a whistleblower represented by the James Hoyer Law Firm in a case against Education Management Corporation (EDMC), the 2nd largest for-profit college provider in the country. Magistrate Judge Cynthia Reed Eddy, of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania, recommends that the case move forward on several key counts.

Former EDMC employee Jason Sobek alleges in the lawsuit that EDMC defrauded the federal government by making misrepresentations which led students to sign up for federal student loans and grants.  Among the issues are misrepresentations on program accreditation and job placement statistics and failing to track student academic progress.

Magistrate Judge Eddy recommends that those three main counts put forth in the suit regarding job placement, accreditation, and satisfactory academic progress proceed–  denying EDMC’s Motion to Dismiss those counts. EDMC schools named in the suit include South University, Agrosy and The Art Institutes.

An article in Law360 reports:

U.S. Magistrate Judge Cynthia Reed Eddy said that  several allegations made by Jason Sobek, a former
EDMC associate admissions officer, are strong enough to go forward, including claims that the Pittsburgh, Pa.-based education company lied to students about its programs’ accreditations and their job prospects.

Magistrate Eddy also says Sobek met the burden of evidence for a claim on “incentive compensation”  to continue, but because the plaintiff was not “first filed” on that issue, she recommends dismissing that count. The “incentive compensation” claim will move forward in a separate whistleblower suit which was first to file on that issue.

The Magistrate recommended that there was not sufficient evidence put forth to continue two other counts in the suit, which had to do with misrepresentations of  cost and a “violation of reverse false claims.”

District Judge Terrance McVerry will now take the Magistrate’s recommendation under advisement and is expected to rule in the near future.